What Should You Do If the Other Driver Changes Their Story?
A driver may describe a collision one way at the scene and give a different account to their insurer. They might initially acknowledge hitting your vehicle, then later shift blame by claiming you changed lanes or stopped unexpectedly. This is more common than you might think. People become frightened after an accident about what might happen to their driving record or insurance rates.
Their changing story does not establish fault. It can complicate a car accident claim, however, particularly when there is little independent evidence of what happened. Preserve your records promptly and ask your adjuster how the new statement affects the assessment.
At McNally Gervan, our Ottawa car accident lawyers review collision evidence alongside the accounts given by everyone involved. Those facts help us assess responsibility and represent people injured in Ottawa and across Eastern Ontario.
Why Might a Driver Change Their Account?
Concern about the insurance consequences of a collision may lead a driver to dispute details they initially accepted. They may offer an explanation that places responsibility on someone else. They might be afraid that they will have to pay their insurance deductible or that their insurance rates will go up on renewal.
Memory can change too. A collision happens quickly, and a person may recall details differently after the initial shock passes. A revised account does not, on its own, establish that the driver is lying. Each version of events needs to be compared with the available evidence.
What If the Other Driver Lies About an Accident?
Ask your adjuster what the other driver now claims and which facts are disputed. Keep a record of the conversation and copies of any correspondence so you can focus on evidence that addresses those specific points. Objective evidence can help counter false claims when the accounts differ.
Preserve Photographs and Recordings
Keep the originals. Photographs and videos from the scene may show vehicle damage and vehicle positions that help explain the collision. Images of skid marks, debris or damage to nearby property can provide further context.
If nearby businesses may have surveillance footage, ask about preservation before it is overwritten. Back up your dashcam footage promptly as well.
Traffic camera footage may not be available. Some systems provide live views without retaining recordings.
While your recollection is still clear, write it down and date the account. Distinguish what you observed from what you learned afterward, and confirm the contact details of any witnesses.
Request the Police Report
Obtain the police report or Collision Reporting Centre report and evaluate it for errors. It may document the drivers’ initial accounts or identify witnesses who can provide more information. Keep any amended reports alongside the original so changes can be assessed against the rest of the evidence.
The report has limits. It may not contain everything said at the scene, and an officer who did not witness the collision must rely on information gathered afterward. Any inconsistencies need to be considered in that context. If you are attending a Collision Reporting Centre to file your own report, describe the accident accurately and make note of any injuries or pain that you are experiencing, even if you haven’t been to the hospital yet.
Give Accurate Statements
Cooperate with your own insurer and meet your policy’s reporting obligations. Describe what you know without guessing at speeds or distances. If you cannot recall a detail, say so.
Correct errors promptly. If an earlier statement contains false information, explain what was wrong and how you discovered the mistake.
Before agreeing to a request for a recorded statement from the other party’s insurer, speak with a lawyer. You generally do not have to provide one to that insurer, and advice may help when responsibility is disputed.
Document Your Injuries and Treatment
Seek medical attention for your symptoms and explain when they began. As recovery progresses, tell your provider about any changes and keep medical records and receipts. If cost or difficulty accessing care interrupts treatment, document the reason.
Medical evidence serves a different purpose from collision evidence: it helps establish the injuries and their connection to the crash. It does not determine which driver caused the collision, but it remains an important part of a personal injury claim.
What Evidence Can Help Resolve the Dispute?
Independent evidence can help assess conflicting accounts. Witness statements may describe the vehicles approaching the collision, while video footage may show the sequence directly.
Vehicle damage patterns require interpretation. Although photos can assist, they may not establish speed or explain every movement. In some car accident cases, an accident reconstruction engineer can provide expert analysis of the physical evidence.
Electronic records may also help. An event data recorder may capture certain vehicle data around the impact, and phone records may help investigate possible distraction. Phone activity alone does not necessarily establish that a driver was looking at a screen.
Some records can be lost quickly.
At McNally Gervan, we assess which records may be relevant and take steps to preserve evidence before it becomes unavailable.
How Do Insurance Companies Determine Fault for Car Damage Claims?
Ontario insurance companies apply the province’s Fault Determination Rules when assessing responsibility for automobile damage. The applicable collision scenario matters, along with the evidence supporting it.
Disagree with the assessment? Ask your adjuster which rule was applied and why, then submit evidence that addresses any factual error. The insurer’s complaint process is another option if the dispute remains unresolved.
An injury lawsuit involves a separate assessment of negligence, so an insurer’s fault percentage does not automatically determine responsibility in court. If an injured person contributed to the collision, contributory negligence may reduce their damages.
Can You Still Receive Accident Benefits?
Accident benefits may be available regardless of who caused the collision. Eligibility and the benefits payable depend on the applicable coverage and circumstances.
Since July 1, 2026, medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits remain mandatory, while benefits such as income replacement are optional. Existing policies renew with their previous coverage and limits unless the policyholder agrees to changes in writing. Review the coverage that applied on the collision date. A separate claim against an at-fault driver may address losses beyond accident benefits, subject to Ontario’s legal requirements. A changed account can affect that claim if it creates a dispute about negligence.
When Should You Speak With a Personal Injury Lawyer?
You do not need to wait for a final fault assessment. Legal representation may help when a changed statement affects an injury claim or the insurer disputes how the crash occurred.
By comparing the accounts with the supporting documentation, personal injury lawyers can assess the dispute and identify records that require preservation. They can also explain your legal options.
Deadlines continue during the investigation. Ontario’s basic limitation period is generally two years from discovery of the claim, often the collision date, subject to exceptions.
Accident benefits have shorter deadlines: you generally must notify the insurer within seven days, or as soon afterward as possible, and return the application within 30 days of receiving it. If you have missed a deadline, seek advice promptly because an explanation for the delay may matter.
Speak With McNally Gervan About a Disputed Collision
A changed story needs to be assessed against reliable evidence. Preserving records early can help establish what happened and support your injury claim.
At McNally Gervan LLP, we review conflicting accounts and the insurance issues that follow an Ontario collision. Contact our team to discuss your rights after an Ottawa or Eastern Ontario car accident.
Follow Us